Bay Shore, NY Property Crime Rates and Maps

Bay Shore is an unincorporated community of 39,300 in Suffolk County, about 40 miles east of Midtown Manhattan · Updated November 2026

How common is property crime in Bay Shore?

Bay Shore earns an A- for property crime, with more property crime than the neighborhoods where 56% of Americans live. Theft makes up 68% of it. Burglary, the crime most likely to reach into a home, grades A+, and vehicle theft grades A-.

A-
Property crime CrimeGrade™Safety score 790 of 1,000
About as much property crime as the typical US neighborhood What this means

44% of Americans live in neighborhoods with more property crime than Bay Shore as a whole, and 56% in neighborhoods with less. The typical US neighborhood has a property crime safety score of 823, a CrimeGrade™ of A-. Bay Shore scores 790.

Crime is concentrated in a small share of places, so most neighborhoods score high on the 0 to 1,000 scale. That is why a score in the 800s can still mean more property crime than most US neighborhoods.

A-
Overall crimeSafety score 834 of 1,000About as safe as the typical US neighborhood
A
Violent crimeSafety score 859 of 1,000About as much violent crime as the typical US neighborhood

How it works


Property crime map of Bay Shore

Map of Bay Shore shaded by property crime CrimeGrade™, from green for the least crime to red for the most
Click the map to explore
F D C B A+
Highest crime Safest
Colorblind friendly off

How to read the map: each area's color compares its property crime with the homes, parked cars and people there, on one national scale, from green for the least to red for the most. Each area gets its own color, so a busy shopping center can show red while the homes beside it stay green. The interactive maps load faster on a strong connection. Compare high speed internet in Bay Shore, NY at ISP Reports.

Who this page is for: homeowners and renters in Bay Shore, and anyone thinking about buying or renting a home there.

Business and enterprise customers: this free map shows neighborhood areas. CrimeGrade™ business reports map crime at about 66-meter detail and estimate it for one address and type of business. See business reports


What stands out about property crime in Bay Shore

Burglary is a strength. Bay Shore grades A- for property crime, but burglary grades A+, better than in the neighborhoods where 73% of Americans live.

Car thefts run high for a city with an A for property crime. Bay Shore has 1.7 car thefts a year per 1,000 residents; for the typical resident of a US city graded A for property crime, the figure is 0.91.


Where property crime is lowest and highest in Bay Shore

Every part of Bay Shore where people live grades A or B for property crime on the national scale. Property crime grades across Bay Shore run from A to B-.

A or B 100%

Share of residents, by the property crime CrimeGrade™ of the area they live in.


Property crime rates and types in Bay Shore

CrimeGrade™ estimates Bay Shore has about 20 reported property crimes a year for every 1,000 residents, 18% less than the US as a whole and close to New York.

All property crime

Burglary

Vehicle theft

Reported crimes a year, per 1,000 residents. Property crime here includes vandalism, which the FBI's property crime rate leaves out.

Theft is the most common property crime in Bay Shore, about 68% of the total, followed by vandalism and vehicle theft.

CrimeCrimeGrade™Reported a yearPer 1,000 residentsUS per 1,000
BurglaryA+200.502.4
TheftB+52013.213.1
Vehicle theftA-651.72.7
ArsonA+10.030.12
VandalismB+1624.15.5

Each CrimeGrade™ here compares a property crime with what it affects: homes for burglary and arson, parked cars for vehicle theft, people and parking for theft, homes and businesses for vandalism. Rates count crimes per 1,000 residents.

Select a crime's name to see its map above. CrimeGrade™ business reports map each crime at about 66-meter detail.


Property crime in Bay Shore and nearby cities

Of the 10 cities closest to Bay Shore, 7 have less property crime. West Islip and East Islip have the least.

Nearby cities

PlacePropertyOverallResidents
Bay ShoreA-790A-39,300
Brightwaters 1 mileA-804A3,180
North Bay Shore 2 milesB+736A-21,100
Islip 2 milesA-846A13,700
Baywood 2 milesA-829A8,180
Show all 10
PlacePropertyOverallResidents
West Islip 3 milesA868A25,500
Brentwood 4 milesB+738A-61,600
North Babylon 4 milesA-787A19,100
East Islip 4 milesA862A14,400
Islip Terrace 4 milesA848A6,160
Deer Park 4 milesA-799A27,700

Nearest first, with each place's distance from Bay Shore. Beside each property crime CrimeGrade™ is its safety score, from 0 to 1,000 (higher is safer).

Compared with cities of similar size and density, Bay Shore has more property crime than 60% of them.

Cities of similar size and density

PlacePropertyOverallResidents
Bay ShoreA-790A-39,300
Buffalo Grove, ILA912A+39,500
Greenwich, CTA899A+39,500
Port Huron, MIA854B+39,100
Litchfield Park, AZA-823A-39,500
Show all 10
PlacePropertyOverallResidents
Mount Laurel, NJA-822A39,500
Bangor, MEA-790B+39,100
Perry Hall, MDA-775A-39,100
Adelanto, CAB+711B+39,200
Lincoln Park, MIB674B39,400
Beverly Hills, CAB646A-39,200

Empty homes, shops and walkability in Bay Shore

Among the traits that tend to go with property crime, two set Bay Shore apart: it has 3.4% of its homes standing empty, against 7.1% nationally, and 1.1 parking-lot spaces per resident, against 2.0 nationally. Places like that tend to report less burglary, vandalism and arson, and burglary runs low here.

Empty homesSeasonal and vacation homes are left out. Places with many empty homes tend to report more burglary, vandalism and arson.3.4% of homesUS: 7.1%Lower than for 81% of US city residents
Stores and restaurantsShops and restaurants draw crowds and parked cars. Places with many stores tend to report more theft.13.4 per 1,000 residentsUS: 10.5Higher than for 79% of US city residents
Walk GradeBestNeighborhood's grade for getting through daily life on foot, traced along real walking routes to shops, schools and parks. Walkable places tend to report more theft. 67% of residents here live in car-dependent areas.C- (28 of 100)US: 21Higher than for 78% of US city residents
Show all 6
Parking lotsBig lots at stores, offices and apartment complexes. Places with more lot space tend to report more theft.1.1 spaces per residentUS: 2.0Lower than for 73% of US city residents
Lit at nightSatellite images show which neighborhoods are lit at night, a sign of busy streets and businesses. Brightly lit places tend to report more theft and vandalism.100% where people liveUS: 78%Higher than for 73% of US city residents
Residents in dense blocksBlocks of 10,000 or more people per square mile. Dense neighborhoods tend to report more car theft.24% of residentsUS: 24%Higher than for 62% of US city residents

BestNeighborhood, a sister site of CrimeGrade™, ranks the neighborhoods of Bay Shore on shops, parks, home prices, getting around and more.

These traits tend to go with more or less crime; none of them causes it on its own. Sources: Census job counts and housing figures, OpenStreetMap and Overture business listings, CrimeGrade™ parking estimates, NASA night-light imagery, US Forest Service tree cover, EPA transit data and BestNeighborhood's Walk Grade.


What property crime costs Bay Shore

Property crime costs Bay Shore about $5.0 million a year, or $128 per resident and about $406 per household: the value of what is stolen or damaged, plus the police, courts and prisons that respond.

Cost of property crime per resident, per year

How the cost breaks down

Pain and suffering add little to the cost of property crime, so this is close to its full cost.

CrimeCost a yearPer resident
Burglary$180,000$5
Theft$2.7 million$68
Vehicle theft$1.0 million$26
Arson$31,000$1
Vandalism$1.2 million$29
Total$5.0 million$128

How CrimeGrade™ works

The property crime CrimeGrade™ covers burglary, theft, car theft, arson and vandalism, from A+ for the least crime to F for the most, on one scale for the whole country.

It weighs each property crime against what it affects: homes for burglary and arson, parked cars for car theft, and the people and parking around stores for theft.

The rates on this page count crimes for every 1,000 people who live here, the way police departments report them.

Comparisons with US neighborhoods use the Census Bureau's block groups, small areas of about 1,400 residents, and count the people who live in each. The figures count crimes reported to police; many crimes, shoplifting above all, never are. Behind the grades, CrimeGrade™ tested 21,607 factors from 125 data families. For business owners, paid CrimeGrade™ location reports estimate crime at a single address for each type of business.

Where the numbers come from

  • Crime reports that police departments file with the FBI
  • State crime records and city crime data, where they are published
  • Population and housing figures from the US Census Bureau
  • Published research on what crime costs victims and communities

These are estimates of reported crime for whole areas, not a record of what happened on any one street. CrimeGrade™ updates them once a year and provides them free and without guarantee. Check local sources before you rely on them for a decision.

More about CrimeGrade™ data